The 15-year-old pulled his car up next to Dunmore Patrolman Patrick Reese’s squad car.
“Pardon me, but do you happen to have any Grey Poupon?” the teen jokingly asked during the August 1992 encounter.
At the time, a humorous television commercial advertised Grey Poupon dijon mustard and featured two formally dressed men lunching in their Rolls Royces. One car pulls up to the other and its occupant asks roughly the same question.
Where others might have seen the humor, Patrolman Reese saw disrespect and cited the teen with disorderly conduct.
“You have to take a stand somewhere,” Patrolman Reese said at the time. “I’m an authority figure and once someone tries to make a fool out of you, that’s half the battle. ... Our job is hard enough as it is without having kids trying to make fools out of us.”
From the archives: Dunmore cop defends action in citing youth, 15, for remark
More than two decades later, the former Dunmore police chief, who fought to return to work after an injury forced his retirement as a police officer, stands accused of lacking the proper respect for a judge’s court order in the grand jury investigation of Ms. Kane.
She hired him two years ago to protect and drive her around and considers him one of her closest confidantes, according to court documents charging him with violating a court order issued by Judge William R. Carpenter, who supervised the Montgomery County-based grand jury.
The order forbid attorney general’s office employees from gaining access to information related to the investigation of Ms. Kane. But last September, an affidavit says, she narrowed the list of people who could search the attorney general’s office’s email archives from eight to three, including Mr. Reese. Starting that day and up until December, Mr. Reese violated the order by searching the archives for grand jury-related information.
The judge issued the order because the attorney general’s office was finding out the names of grand jury witnesses and when they would testify and acquiring transcripts of grand jury testimony. Witnesses were being confronted “as they arrived to testify and (were) subject to intimidating conduct,” according to the probable cause affidavit against Mr. Reese. The affidavit does not specifically say he did any of that, but accuses him of entering search terms in the email archive to seek grand jury activity documentation.
He refused to cooperate with the grand jury that investigated Ms. Kane, according to the probable cause affidavit charging her with perjury, official oppression and obstructing the administration of law.
Ms. Kane plucked him from his post as Dunmore’s chief in early 2013 and offered him a salary of about $95,000.
By then, Mr. Reese had a reputation as a tough, anti-drug cop in two decades on the force. He was a longtime member of the Lackawanna-Scranton Drug Task Force and the borough’s Drug Abuse Resistance Education officer in schools. In December 1992, then-Dunmore Police Chief Frank Occulto said, someone set Patrolman Reese’s parked private vehicle on fire in response to a drug investigation. No one was ever charged with the arson.
Lackawanna County District Attorney Andy Jarbola said he considers Mr. Reese “a nice guy.”
“But he was a very thorough cop and police chief. I always found him to be a very thorough guy,” Mr. Jarbola said.
James Boland, another former Dunmore chief who came up through the borough police ranks with Mr. Reese, remembered his colleague similarly.
“In his drug work, he didn’t like drugs and he did his best to keep them off the street,” Mr. Boland said. “He took his job very seriously.”
His drug work once landed him in the midst of a major controversy that encircled the department.
About 1:30 a.m. on April 29, 1998, another Dunmore patrolman pulled over a car that ran a red light. Inside was passenger Thomas Harrison, at the time the county tax claim bureau director, who got out to speak to the officer and dropped a small plastic bag drop containing a “white, powdery substance that appeared to be cocaine.”
The incident stayed a secret until September 1999 when Mr. Harrison ran — unsuccessfully, ultimately — for county commissioner.
Mr. Reese, by then a borough police captain and its drug officer, took over the investigation the night of the traffic stop. Back then, he said a field test showed the powder tested negative for cocaine. But as it turned out, the test was positive and he held off on a drug charge because he turned Mr. Harrison into an informant.
Almost four years later, as federal prosecutors finally pressed the same drug case against Mr. Harrison, Mr. Reese, a captain by then, admitted the powder “tested positive for cocaine” within hours of the stop. Mr. Harrison eventually pleaded guilty to a federal drug charge and was sentenced to a year of probation.
Mr. Reese’s elevation to captain was shrouded in controversy, too.
He had failed a civil service test to become a sergeant when Mayor Patrick Loughney promoted him and two others in January 1996 to acting captain to replace two captains on sick leave. Four years later, the three acting captains still hadn’t taken a civil service test to remain captains because the borough never gave one.
In 2004, Mr. Reese suffered a serious neck injury in the basement of the borough police building when an audio speaker fell on him while he was moving a file cabinet. The injury forced his retirement. But in March 2009, the borough council reinstated him — as police chief.
“He is as dedicated as they come,” Councilman Thomas Hennigan said then. “Politics has nothing — nothing — to do with this.”
Mr. Boland, the chief at the time, said Mr. Reese wanted to return to work and found a doctor who cleared him to return if he wasn’t required to be the first on the scene of a police call in case physicality was required. A year short of retirement, Mr. Boland said he voluntarily agreed to return to being assistant police chief so his former colleague could return to the force as chief.
“He was a good, dedicated officer, dedicated to the citizens of the borough,” Mr. Boland said.
Contact the writer: bkrawczeniuk@timesshamrock.com