Three Scranton city councilmen want the Mall at Steamtown’s anchor tenant to reconsider blocking major changes at the troubled retail space.
As vacancy increased at the shopping center on Lackawanna Avenue in recent years, more area residents have talked about different visions for how the mall could remain a viable part of downtown Scranton.
A proposal to convert the building into a Reading Terminal-style market gained significant social media momentum in recent months, while architect Michele Dempsey’s team drew up a plan for the mall to become a “mixed-use lifestyle center” with lofts, retail storefronts, restaurants and offices.
Other ideas have ranged from turning the mall into a casino to converting it into a skating rink.
But the mall’s lease agreement with Boscov’s Department Store allows the anchor tenant to veto significant changes. Store Chairman Al Boscov told The Times-Tribune earlier this week that the store probably would bid on the mall at an auction next month with a goal of keeping the facility all or predominantly retail.
He wanted to keep people with ideas about repurposing the mall — some of whom he called “cranks” — away from the auction scheduled by LNR Partners.
“I was very upset to read an article in the newspaper featuring Al Boscov talking about the mall,” Councilman Pat Rogan said at Thursday’s meeting. “Mr. Boscov criticized and even poked fun at many of the great ideas that have been put forward by the residents of Scranton to rehab that building. Obviously, the current formula that Mr. Boscov has a leading role in didn’t work. I was just at the mall last Tuesday, and it is a ghost town.”
Although he felt the overall mall concept is no longer working, Mr. Rogan said Boscov’s has been successful in the space and should continue to have an important role there.
Council President Bob McGoff also had some strong words for Mr. Boscov, who he hoped would give up what he called “obstinacy to change.”
“I believe that Mr. Boscov is a great businessman,” Mr. McGoff said. “However, I don’t think Mr. Boscov has been very good for the city of Scranton. I think as the mall goes to auction — and it would appear that Mr. Boscov is doing everything he can to purchase the mall — he needs to be willing to consider options. ... We cannot persist in the mall structure as it is.”
Like Mr. Rogan, he felt Boscov’s should nonetheless maintain its presence there.
After the meeting, Councilman Bill Gaughan said retail trends at malls across the country indicate the facility needs a new direction.
During his interview earlier this week, Mr. Boscov indicated he might be open to a different use for the building’s second floor. He talked about attracting other retailers back to the mall, reopening negotiations with potential anchor tenants to replace Bon-Ton and seeking state grants to repair the parking garage.
“We can’t do anything now because we don’t own it,” Mr. Boscov said at the time. “But we can make it work and we can make it relevant to the community.”
In other business Thursday, council introduced an ordinance that would expand requirements for utilities to restore roads after tearing them up for various projects, Mr. Gaughan said.
The ordinance would also ban excavating city streets within five years of a paving project, except in emergency situations, which he said could include upgrades, improvements or maintenance to utility systems.
“All you need to do is drive on our city streets to experience an enormous amount of bumpy, uneven pave cuts that drive city motorists crazy,” Mr. Gaughan said. “It has not been uncommon in the past to drive down a newly paved city street one week and the next week find the street has been dug up by a utility company.”
Also, Mayor Bill Courtright and consultant Henry Amoroso are working with council to schedule a discussion to update city lawmakers on Scranton’s recovery plan at an upcoming public caucus or meeting.
Contact the writer:
kwind@timesshamrock.com, @kwindTT on Twitter